Boise locals recently gathered on Reddit to reminisce about beloved restaurants of the past, sparking a wave of mouthwatering memories. One name rose to the top of the thread like the cream in fresh coffee — Brick Oven Beanery/Bistro. For many, this iconic eatery wasn’t just a place to eat; it was a slice of Boise’s heart and soul, now missed.

Why the Brick Oven Beanery Was Boise’s Darling

The Brick Oven Beanery wasn’t about flashy trends or over-complicated dishes. It was honest-to-goodness comfort food done right. From hearty soups and artisanal sandwiches to drool-worthy baked goods, this place knew how to warm both belly and spirit. Oh, and the bread? Absolutely legendary. Some Redditors joked it might have tasted even better because of the cozy, welcoming energy the space exuded.

But the Beanery wasn’t just about food. It was part of the stories that made up Boise’s everyday life. One user said, "Omg. I miss their turkey sandwiches and corn chowder potatoes."

A Community’s Love Affair with the Past

The thread didn’t stop there. Other long-lost favorites like The Gamekeeper, Pollo Rey, and Bluebird also earned honorable mentions, with commenters recounting vivid, heartfelt stories. But the love for the Brick Oven Beanery was at the top of the list, standing as a reminder that food is never just food.

For those who miss the Beanery’s homestyle goodness and warm ambiance, the memories will keep its legacy alive in Boise's collective heart. Wouldn’t we all love just one more slice of that bread and one more quiet morning there? One person on the thread did say, " I used to cook there for about five years. I believe the owner released a recipe book with all the classics in it like the cheddar vegetable soup, corn gravy, Carolina chicken, etc." Here's the link.

Out of all the Boise restaurants that have closed which one would you like to see brought back from the dead?
byu/ForestCervixRd524 inBoise